It’s not an ideas post itself, but most of the replies are of new ideas that are pretty interesting to read/consider.
Best of the Best Nominations - December 2017
BaraBlazer
#29
Those who calls himself king has no right to be one.
Also, shameless plug, even though this wasn’t my proudest idea. It certainly is the most popular one.
Personally, I want to go with the clocktower but since that has been taken,
This dungeon is criminally underlooked.
Xaklor
#30
well would you look at that
clock tower is the top non-shitpost idea that isn’t in there already
on a more serious note, I sincerely hope that the square set does not get moved. yes, it’s really funny, I’ll admit that. but we get enough admittedly stupid and mind-bogglingly half-assed shitposts that get passed off as “ideas” as it is. setting a role model for them only increases their number, and as moderators have insisted numerous times: “We’re not reddit”.
to the next five people who tell me I’m “wrong” and that the square set “must be moved”: 10,000 shames upon your house. even the best joke is still a joke.
Catbattle
#32
Clock tower. As a dungeon designer myself, its a complete masterpiece and I would love to see it.
Puffagod
#34
I hope it doesn’t become flooded with sub-par ideas after the first few rounds…
Maybe put a special ‘vintage’ tag on the ones already up there or edit their descriptions to explain that they were the original elite, I rather enjoyed feeling special!
That said, this should have been up there long ago:
Seelpit
#35
It’s an idea, though not for an item, so it does count!
Also because I really can’t think of anything that amazing that I genuinely liked. For real.
I’m not that selfish I swear
CandyShi
#36
I’d nominate the clock tower, but it’s been nominated enough times.
I’ll just add +1 to the nomination
XHippobroX
#37
Here are two more I think are good
and
Maybe not best of the best but definitely worth considering imo
Sturky
#41
Well, to not seem like a scrub and nominate my own stuff ( And because I haven’t gotten to the juicy meat of my ideas yet, we’re merely putting the seasonings on. ) Imma just nominate The Clock Tower.
Also I’ve noticed a lot of people are nominating the Clock Tower, so place your bets lads, Will the Clock Tower win?
- Yes
- No
0 voters
Atrapper
#42
I’d like to nominate two ideas:
The Clock Tower, by @Xaklor. This dungeon idea is undoubtedly one of the best ideas I’ve seen in a while. It introduces great new mechanics, introduces interesting and intriguing lore, and provides great boss battles. Additionally, the idea of Lore Scrolls is something I would love to see implemented through the entire game!
Dapper Ideas and Classy Classes by @Dappertron. I’ll split my comments into 2 parts:
Dapper Ideas: Dapper Ideas introduces many new, interesting weapons, some being as sweet and simple as a Doom Bow Staff, with others being as unique and interesting as split shots!
Classy Classes: Have you ever wanted to summon bird allies or latch onto enemies and deal massive damage to them? If so, you’d love Classy Classes! It introduces some of the most interesting class ideas I’ve heard of and includes 14 of them (if they were all added, the class number would be tripled!).