Re-opened. This is still a forum bug, as shown by:
Can we plox fix the stars? [now fixed, Apr '19]
Nevov
#25
The forum still awards stars based on the game when it had 14 classes (70 stars).
There’s a forum bug topic about this, I’ll move your posts there as a bump to that topic.
EDIT: looks like this issue is now fixed.
OtherBill
#26
The forums used to show me as a white star. I didn’t log out and log back in, and it bumped me down to yellow anyway.
[I guess I need to go grind out that final 1,000 fame on my Sammy, now… OB]