You ARE being rude. We are trying to have a civilized discussion on a topic you brought up, and you have not taken some of the criticism with much grace. The player you called a “smartass”, Mynamerr, was only trying to help, and is well-known throughout the community for being level-headed, mature and courteous to others. Insulting him hasn’t helped your case in the slightest.
With that out of the way, I am still interested in how your idea gets rid of the many problems with the current system (as I highlighted in my previous post).