Does the like button count as a +1 nomination? If someone nominates something just like their post instead of posting it again? If not probably should because that makes the most sense.
Best of the Best Nominations - December 2017
I was thinking so, yes. “Top 10” is a bit vague, but it will be some combination of nomination count + nomination like count + idea thread replies + idea thread likes.
Well would you look at that
Square set coming in at number 4 (number 1 out of non-best of the best ideas)
I gotta say, the demigod class and ST Square set gave me a good laugh.
https://www.realmeye.com/forum/t/demigod-new-class-idea/11581I nominate this.
Why?
Well its pretty good, not that great but good…
But Puffagod, who has gotten into the Best o Best 2 times, believes
If he thinks its worthy, I do too.
I honestly think that this post deserves it, but I highly doubt it’s going to win. Still worth a shot though
Best of the Best is for ideas, not best threads on the entire forum.
Though that’s not a bad idea for a new year thing.
It’s not an ideas post itself, but most of the replies are of new ideas that are pretty interesting to read/consider.
Those who calls himself king has no right to be one.
Also, shameless plug, even though this wasn’t my proudest idea. It certainly is the most popular one.
Personally, I want to go with the clocktower but since that has been taken,
This dungeon is criminally underlooked.
well would you look at that
clock tower is the top non-shitpost idea that isn’t in there already
on a more serious note, I sincerely hope that the square set does not get moved. yes, it’s really funny, I’ll admit that. but we get enough admittedly stupid and mind-bogglingly half-assed shitposts that get passed off as “ideas” as it is. setting a role model for them only increases their number, and as moderators have insisted numerous times: “We’re not reddit”.
to the next five people who tell me I’m “wrong” and that the square set “must be moved”: 10,000 shames upon your house. even the best joke is still a joke.
Clock tower. As a dungeon designer myself, its a complete masterpiece and I would love to see it.
I hope it doesn’t become flooded with sub-par ideas after the first few rounds…
Maybe put a special ‘vintage’ tag on the ones already up there or edit their descriptions to explain that they were the original elite, I rather enjoyed feeling special!
That said, this should have been up there long ago:
It’s an idea, though not for an item, so it does count!
Also because I really can’t think of anything that amazing that I genuinely liked. For real.
I’m not that selfish I swear
I’d nominate the clock tower, but it’s been nominated enough times.
I’ll just add +1 to the nomination